WASHINGTON - Dozens of former U.S.
military leaders, federal judges and diplomats Thursday challenged
the indefinite detentions at Guantánamo as a legal mistake that has
undermined the rule of law, U.S. standing in the world and will
endanger Americans in future conflicts.
Seven groups have filed friend-of-the-court briefs urging the
Supreme Court to examine the Guantánamo detentions. So far, U.S.
courts have held that because the naval base in Cuba is foreign
territory, U.S. law does not apply and detainees have no standing in
federal courts.
Those urging a review include two retired admirals and a Marine
Corps general, six former federal judges, 19 retired diplomats, the
Commonwealth Bar Association representing Britain and 53 other
countries, and three former POWs who survived captivity in World War
II.
Former Adm. Donald Guter, who retired last year as the Navy judge
advocate general, was in the Pentagon on Sept. 11, 2001, and was a
participant in the decisions that led to the Guantánamo detentions
and military tribunals:
''I have absolutely no sympathy for terrorists,'' he said, ``but
now I'm worried that we're looking at a lot of life sentences
without due process or judicial review. And that can hurt us around
the world and when our own people are taken captive.''